The Spam Club

» The Spam Club - Reviewed Games - Comments / Discussion - The Perfect General II (1994)
ReplyNew TopicNew Poll

The Perfect General II (1994)

Posted at 08:31 on June 12th, 2021 | Quote | Edit | Delete
Dr Gumby
Posts: 276
The first strategy game I seriously played and loved was Dune II: Battle for Arrakis. Before that, I was absolutely not interested in this genre. I never found it particularly exciting to virtually push some combat units around on a map. But Dune 2 nevertheless cast its spell on me and has not let go of many of us to this day. A whole bunch of successors poured over the audience in the years that followed. However, these clones soon lost the appeal of the new. Perhaps I would have found these fresh ideas in other – less well-known – representatives of the genre back then. In search of such pearls, I enter the famous hexa fields of The Perfect General II.

A programmer is just a tool which converts caffeine into code.
Posted at 08:57 on June 12th, 2021 | Quote | Edit | Delete
Reborn Gumby
Posts: 9693
If you've got the perfect game, why change anything? Yup, exactly. The Perfect General II is… the first game all over again. Changes are so scarce that it's almost impudent. Or bold. It's a game which makes one think how on earth they thought they could get away with it and keep face, because nothing has changed.

Virtually nothing, that is. There are few new units. An even heavier tank beyond the existing "heavy" one. An airplane which acts exactly as artillery, i.e. its attacks need to be planned one turn in advance and it is equally vulnerable to direct counterattacks. None add anything to the overall game.

It is like all those games in between which made their information less abstract never happened. No Battle Isle 2. No Panzer General.

But then, in spite of everything, you find yourself drawn in again. By the phase model requiring such complex forward thinking. By the line-of sight handling. By the different unit abilities. By pass fire opportunities during the opponent's turn. By the attacker/defender duality and the related application of the scoring system, which won't always simply declare the player who eventually manages to conquer the map the winner.

All this is because The Perfect General II changes nothing. It is a very, very good game. It is truly abysmal, despicable as a full priced release. It contains cringeworthy video clips of "military commanders" dressed up in costumes silly beyond any known standard, saying useless, painfully unfunny things. It's so good it's hard to stop playing. If you've been a veteran of the first part. Otherwise, you most certainly won't be converted.
Now you see the violence inherent in the system!
ReplyNew TopicNew Poll
Powered by Spam Board 5.2.4 © 2007 - 2011 Spam Board Team